When Silence Means No
Monday July 21st 2008, 7:31 am
Filed under: notes
Filed under: notes
I’ve learned that as a freelancer, if I don’t hear from a client, that generally means no: no, we don’t want to hire you, no, we don’t have what you need, no, please leave us alone. Of course, silence can also mean: I’m on vacation, I’m very busy, or, my personal favorite, You are bothering me. Sometimes it’s just hard to tell.
Steve at All Things Workplace explores how “no” varies among cultures:
- American Bob works for a German company. Whenever he makes a request for something he has learned that if the answer is “No,” he actually receives no answer. The issue is allowed to melt away over time.
- While working across the Middle East for a couple of years, I realized that the word “No” was never uttered in any meeting I attended.
- I watched a client’s sales presentation in Portugal. Suddenly the room filled with palpable tension. What happened? He responded with a simple, direct, “No” to a request from the client.
Does anyone have any experience with “no” in other cultures? I’m trying to remember hearing “no” when I taught at an Indian school in Santa Fe, but I have no memory of “no.” It may not have been done.
I’ve learned that as a complainant, silence from the “culture” of the UUA, and its very aptly named Ministerial Fellowship Committee, to say nothing of individual U*U “churches”, almost always means an emphatic “no” to those who dare to complain about clergy misconduct of various kinds, including clergy sexual misconduct. It means no, we don’t want to hear from you, no, we won’t provide what you need, no, please leave us alone. Of course, silence can also mean: I’m on vacation or I’m very busy, but such silence should only last a few weeks. After that it becomes the negligent and effectively complicit silence of the unfortunate “culture” of institutional stonewalling and denial that the UUA has yet to responsibly move away from inspite of empty promises to “bend towards justice.” It’s really not all that hard to tell.
Anyone who has any doubts about my take on this can get a second opinion from uugrrl’s ‘Speaking Truth To Power’ blog here -
http://uutruth.blogspot.com/search?q=silence
Comment by The Emerson Avengah 07.21.08 @ 9:18 amThere’s always the koan no.
http://www.boundlesswayzen.org/teishos/blacker-noteisho.html
Comment by James 07.21.08 @ 11:02 amwhen we lived in Papua New Guinea they didn’t like to say no
Comment by Kel 07.21.08 @ 9:45 pmso they would say yes
then not show up, do the job, or whatever it was they had said yes to
it was an extremely frustrating two years
It’s a wonder to me that anyone actually does communicate. Thanks for sharing these stories, guys. And James, I’m still wrapping my head around the koan no.
Comment by Ms. Theologian 07.22.08 @ 7:20 amLeave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>