Surviving the Playground
Tuesday January 22nd 2008, 5:01 pm
Filed under: news

I won’t say this is the freakiest thing I’ve ever read because I worked at a junior and senior high schools and noticed that many girls showed up far further into womanhood than I was as an adult. However, breasts at age 8 is now considered within normal range.

Until 10 years ago, breast development at age 8 was considered an abnormal event that should be investigated by an endocrinologist. Then a landmark study in the April 1997 journal Pediatrics written by Marcia Herman-Giddens, adjunct professor at the School of Public Health at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, found that among 17,000 girls in North Carolina, almost half of African Americans and 15% of whites had begun breast development by age 8. Two years later, the society suggested changing what it considered medically normal.

The new “8″ — the medically suggested definition for abnormally early breast development — is, the society says, 7 for white girls and 6 for African American girls. [Ed note: And the rest of you? You don’t count. Kidding. Article ignores Latinas and everyone else.]

Potential causes? Obesity and environmental pollutants that mess with the endocrine system. Potential problems? All that emotional stuff that goes along with puberty that you may not be ready for at 8.



6 Comments so far

Wow. I wonder if there are parts of the country, or more specifics that might give us some clues as to whom this might affect. I certainly see young adolescent girls who appear five to six years older than they are because of their development, but then I see many who look very much like little girls. Is it because some of them are eating differently, living near waste facilities, etc?

Maybe I should read the article.

Comment by h sofia 01.22.08 @ 6:44 pm

I couldn’t access the article, but it is of interest to me because despite being raised on an organic, primarily vegetarian diet, and having limited exposure to chemicals in our home, it appears to me that my own daughter seems to be physically maturing much more quickly than most of her peers. The biggest concern for me as a parent, even more than health issues, is having to discuss things with my child that she may not be mentally and emotionally mature enough to fully deal with. I have to admit that I thought our lifestyle would somehow protect us from this issue, but it goes to show what I’ve found to be true about parenting all along- you prepare, prepare, prepare, and it’s the last thing you expect to encounter that sneaks up and bites you in the…you know.

Comment by BB 01.22.08 @ 6:57 pm

I really wish that chemicals would be allowed into the environment after there is evidence that they are safe, rather than until there is evidence they are not.

Am I a freak for not remembering how old I was when I started menstruating?

Comment by Anne P 01.22.08 @ 6:57 pm

You can find it, BB, on the latimes.com website under Health and it’s the feature article. I’ll try linking again, but I think you might need to register “Girl You’ll be a Woman Sooner than You Think.”

Comment by Ms. Theologian 01.22.08 @ 7:37 pm

Interesting article topic. My sister looked like a teenager around 10 or 11, but it took me decently into junior high (at least 13) for everyone to really notice I was becoming a woman. I think she and I both got our periods around 12; I know that’s when I got mine. That doesn’t bode well for trying to help a young GIRL deal with boys snapping her bra straps, etc.

Comment by Mile High Pixie 01.22.08 @ 7:50 pm

Indeed, the point at which sexual maturation is defined is rapidly growing earlier and earlier.

The question remains if the pace at which females grow into their womanhood physically correlate to their psychological development. My initial response is no, though I’m sure there are conflicting studies on that very topic out and about right this minutes.

Comment by Comrade Kevin 01.23.08 @ 6:25 pm



Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)